ASHAWire
Advanced search
Skip main navigation
Close Drawer MenuOpen Drawer Menu
No AccessEditor's AwardJournal of Speech, Language, and Hearing ResearchResearch Article1 Dec 2005

Are Specific Language Impairment and Dyslexia Distinct Disorders?

    https://doi.org/10.1044/1092-4388(2005/096)

    Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine whether specific language impairment (SLI) and dyslexia are distinct developmental disorders.

    Method: Study 1 investigated the overlap between SLI identified in kindergarten and dyslexia identified in 2nd, 4th, or 8th grades in a representative sample of 527 children. Study 2 examined phonological processing in a subsample of participants, including 21 children with dyslexia only, 43 children with SLI only, 18 children with SLI and dyslexia, and 165 children with typical language/reading development. Measures of phonological awareness and nonword repetition were considered.

    Results: Study 1 showed limited but statistically significant overlap between SLI and dyslexia. Study 2 found that children with dyslexia or a combination of dyslexia and SLI performed significantly less well on measures of phonological processing than did children with SLI only and those with typical development. Children with SLI only showed only mild deficits in phonological processing compared with typical children.

    Conclusions: These results support the view that SLI and dyslexia are distinct but potentially comorbid developmental language disorders. A deficit in phonological processing is closely associated with dyslexia but not with SLI when it occurs in the absence of dyslexia.

    References

    • Adams, C. V., & BishopD. V. M. (2002, July). Genetic influences on verb morphology deficits in 6-year-old twins. Poster presented at the joint conference of the International Association for the Study of Child Language and the Symposium for Research on Children with Language Disorders, Madison, WI.
      Google Scholar
    • Badian, N., McAnulty, G., Duffy, G., & Als, H. S. (1990). Prediction of dyslexia in kindergarten boys.Annals of Dyslexia, 41, 221–243.
      Google Scholar
    • Bedore, L. M., & Leonard, L. B. (1998). Specific language impairment and grammatical morphology: A discriminant function analysis.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 41, 1185–1192.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Berkson, J. (1946). Limitations of the application of fourfold table analysis to hospital data.Biometrics, 2, 47–53.
      Google Scholar
    • Bishop, D. V. M. (2001). Genetic influences on language impairment and literacy problems in children: Same or different?.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 42, 189–198.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Bishop, D. V. M. (2005). DeFries–Fulker analysis of twin data with skewed distributions: Cautions and recommendations from a study of children’s use of verb inflections.Behaviour Genetics, 35, 479–490.
      Google Scholar
    • Bishop, D. V. M., & Adams, C. (1990). A prospective study of the relationship between specific language impairment, phonological disorders, and reading retardation.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 31, 1027–1050.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Bishop, D. V. M., Adams, C. V., & Norbury, C. F. (2004). Using nonword repetition to distinguish genetic and environmental influences on early literacy development: A study of 6-year-old twins.American Journal of Medical Genetics: Neuropsychiatric Genetics, 129, 94–96.
      Google Scholar
    • Bishop, D. V. M., North, T., & Donlan, C. (1996). Nonword repetition as a behavioral marker for inherited language impairment: Evidence from a twin study.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 37, 391–403.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Bishop, D. V. M., & Snowling, M. J. (2004). Developmental dyslexia and specific language impairment: Same or different?.Psychological Bulletin, 130, 858–886.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Bradley, L., & Bryant, P. E. (1983). Categorising sounds and learning to read—A causal connection.Nature, 301, 419–521.
      Google Scholar
    • Brady, S., Poggie, E., & Rapala, M. M. (1989). Speech repetition abilities in children who differ in reading skill.Language and Speech, 32, 109–122.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Brady, S., Shankweiler, D., & Mann, V. (1983). Speech perception and memory coding in relation to reading ability.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 35, 345–367.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Briscoe, J., Bishop, D. V. M., & Norbury, C. F. (2001). Phonological processing, language, and literacy: A comparison of children with mild-to-moderate sensorineural hearing loss and those with specific language impairment.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 42, 329–340.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Caron, C., & Rutter, M. (1991). Comorbidity in child psychopathology: Concepts, issues and research strategies.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 32, 1063–1080.
      Google Scholar
    • Catts, H. W. (1986). Speech production/phonological deficits in reading-disordered children.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 19, 504–508.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Catts, H. W. (1993). The relationship between speech– language impairments and reading disabilities.Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 36, 948–958.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Catts, H. W., Adlof, S. M., & Ellis WeismerS. (in press). Language deficits in poor comprehenders: A case for the simple view of reading.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research.
      Google Scholar
    • Catts, H. W., Fey, M. E., Tomblin, J. B., & Zhang, X. (1999). Language basis of reading and reading disabilities.Scientific Studies of Reading, 3, 331–361.
      Google Scholar
    • Catts, H. W., Fey, M. E., Tomblin, J. B., & Zhang, X. (2002). A longitudinal investigation of reading outcomes in children with language impairments.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 45, 1142–1157.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Catts, H. W., Fey, M. E., Zhang, X., & Tomblin, J. B. (2001). Estimating the risk of future reading difficulties in kindergarten children: A research-based model and its clinical implications.Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 32, 38–50.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Catts, H. W., & Kamhi, A. G. (2005). Language and reading disabilities.2nd ed.). Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
      Google Scholar
    • Conti-Ramsden, G., Botting, N., & Faragher, B.(2001). Psycholinguistic markers for specific language impairment (SLI).Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 42, 741–748.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Culatta, B., Page, J., & Ellis, J. (1983). Story retelling as a communicative performance screening tool.Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 14, 66–74.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Dollaghan, C. A. (2004). Taxometric analyses of specific language impairment in 3and 4-year-old children.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 47, 464–475.
      Google Scholar
    • Dollaghan, C. A., & Campbell, T. F. (1998). Nonword repetition and child language impairment.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 41, 1136–1146.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Dunn, L. M., & Dunn, L. M. (1981). Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test—Revised.Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
      Google Scholar
    • Dykman, R. A., & Ackerman, P. T. (1992). Diagnosing dyslexia: IQ regression plus cut points.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 574–576.
      Google Scholar
    • Edwards, J. D., & Lahey, M. (1998). Nonword repetitions of children with specific language impairment: Exploration of some explanations for their inaccuracies.Applied Psycholinguistics, 19, 279–309.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Elbro, C. (1996). Early linguistic abilities and reading development: A review and a hypothesis.Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 8, 453–485.
      Google Scholar
    • Ellis Weismer, S., Tomblin, J. B., Zhang, X., Buckwalter, P., Chynoweth, J. G., & Jones, M. (2000). Nonword repetition performance in school-age children with and without language impairment.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 43, 865–878.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Fletcher, J. M., Shaywitz, S. E., Shankweiler, D. P., Katz, L., Liberman, I. Y., Stuebing, K. K., et al. (1994). Cognitive profiles of reading disability: Comparisons of discrepancy and low achievement definitions.Journal of Educational Psychology, 86, 6–23.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Frankenberger, W., & Fronzaglio, K. (1991). A review of states’ criteria and procedures for identifying children with learning disabilities.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 24, 495–500.
      Google Scholar
    • Gallagher, A., Frith, U., & Snowling, M. J. (2000). Precursors of literacy delay among children at genetic risk of dyslexia.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 41, 202–213.
      Google Scholar
    • Gathercole, S. E., & Baddeley, A. D. (1990). Phonological memory deficits in language disordered children: Is there a causal connection?.Journal of Memory and Language, 29, 336–360.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Gayan, J., & Olson, R. K. (2003). Genetic and environmental influences on individual differences in printed word recognition.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 84, 97–123.
      Google Scholar
    • Gillon, G. T. (2004). Phonological awareness: From research to practice.New York: Guilford Press.
      Google Scholar
    • Hogan, T. P., Catts, H. W., & Little, T. (2005). The relationship between phonological awareness and reading: Implications for the assessment of phonological awareness.Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 36, 285–293.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Hulme, C., & Snowling, M. J. (1992). Deficits in output phonology: An explanation of reading failure?.Cognitive Neuropsychology, 9, 47–72.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Joffe, V. L. (1998). Rhyming and related skills in children with specific language impairment.Cahiers de Psychologie Cognitive/Current Psychology of Cognition, 17, 479–512.
      Google Scholar
    • Kamhi, A. G., & Catts, H. W. (1986). Toward an understanding of developmental language and reading disorders.Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 51, 337–347.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Leonard, L. B. (1998). Children with specific language impairment.Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
      Google Scholar
    • LoBello, S. G. (1991). Intelligence testing with the WISC–R.New York: Wiley.
      Google Scholar
    • Lyon, G. R., Shaywitz, S. E., & Shaywitz, B. A. (2003). A definition of dyslexia.Annals of Dyslexia, 53, 1–14.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Lyytinen, H., Ahonen, T., Eklund, K., Guttorm, T. K., Laakso, M. L., Leinonen, S., et al. (2001). Developmental pathways of children with and without familial risk for dyslexia during the first years of life.Developmental Neuropsychology, 20, 535–554.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Lyytinen, P., Poikkeus, A. M., Laakso, M. L., Eklund, K., & Lyytinen, H. (2001). Language development and symbolic play in children with and without familial risk for dyslexia.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 44, 873–885.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • McArthur, G. M., Hogben, J. H., Edwards, V. T., HeathS. M., & Mengler, E. D. (2000). On the “specifics” of specific reading disability and specific language impairment.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 41, 869–874.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • McGuinness, D., McGuinness, C., & Donohue, J. (1995). Phonological training and the alphabet principle: Evidence for reciprocal causality.Reading Research Quarterly, 30, 830–852.
      Google Scholar
    • Metsala, J. L., & Walley, A. C. (1998). Spoken vocabulary growth and the segmental restructuring of lexical representations: Precursors to phonemic awareness and early reading ability.In L. C. Ehri & J. L. Metsala (Eds.) Word recognition in beginning literacy (pp. 89–120). Mahwah, NJ:Erlbaum.
      Google Scholar
    • Meyer, M. S., Wood, F. B., Hart, L. A., & Felton, R. H. (1998). Selective predictive value of rapid automatized naming in poor readers.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 31, 106–117.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Miller, C., Kail, R., Leonard, L., & Tomblin, J. B. (2001). Speed of processing in children with specific language impairment.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 44, 416–433.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Montgomery, J. W. (2000). Verbal working memory and sentence comprehension in children with specific language impairments.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 43, 293–308.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Nathan, L., Stackhouse, J., Goulandris, N., & Snowling, M. J. (2004). The development of early literacy skills among children with speech difficulties: A test of the Critical Age Hypothesis.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 47, 377–391.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Nation, K. (2005). Connections between language and reading in children with poor reading comprehension.In H. W. Catts & A. G. Kamhi (Eds.) Connections between language and reading disabilities (pp. 41–54). Mahwah, NJ:Erlbaum.
      Google Scholar
    • Nation, K., Clarke, P., Marshall, C. M., & Durand, M. (2004). Hidden language impairments in children: Parallels between poor reading comprehension and specific language impairments?.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 47, 199–211.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Nation, K., & Snowling, M. J. (1997). Individual differences in contextual facilitation: Evidence from dyslexia and poor reading comprehension.Child Development, 69, 996–1011.
      Google Scholar
    • Newcomer, P., & Hammill, D. (1988). Test of Language Development—Primary.2nd ed.). Austin, TX:Pro-Ed.
      Google Scholar
    • Oakhill, J. V., & Yuill, N. (1996). Higher order factors in comprehension disability: Processes and remediation.In C. Cornoldi & J. V. Oakhill (Eds.) Reading comprehension difficulties (pp. 69–92). Mahwah, NJ:Erlbaum.
      Google Scholar
    • Paul, R. (2001). Language disorders from infancy to adolescence: Assessment and intervention.St. Louis, MO: Mosby.
      Google Scholar
    • Pennington, B. F., Gilger, J. W., Olson, R. K., & DeFries, J. C. (1992). The external validity of ageversus IQdiscrepancy definitions of a reading disability: Lessons from a twin study.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 562–573.
      Google Scholar
    • Plaza, M., Cohen, H., & Chevrie-Muller, C. (2001). Oral language deficits in dyslexic children: Weaknesses in working memory and verbal planning.Tennet, XII, 505–512.
      Google Scholar
    • Raskind, W. H., Hsu, L., Berninger, V. W., Thomson, J. B., & Wijsman, E. M. (2000). Family aggregation of dyslexia phenotypes.Behavior Genetics, 30, 385–396.
      Google Scholar
    • Rice, M. L., Hoffman, L., Tomblin, J. B., Richman, W. A., & Marquis, J. (2004). Grammatical tense deficits in children with SLI and nonspecific language impairment: Relationships with nonverbal IQ over time.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 47, 816–834.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Rice, M. L., & Wexler, K. (1996). Toward tense as a clinical marker of specific language impairment in English-speaking children.Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 39, 1239–1257.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Rutter, M., & Yule, W. (1975). The concept of specific reading retardation.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 16, 181–197.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Scarborough, H. S. (1990). Very early language deficits in dyslexic children.Child Development, 61, 1728–1743.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Scarborough, H. S. (1991). Early syntactic development of dyslexic children.Annals of Dyslexia, 41, 207–220.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Scarborough, H. S. (2005). Developmental relationship between language and reading: Reconciling a beautiful hypothesis with some ugly facts.In H. W. Catts & A. G. Kamhi (Eds.) Connections between language and reading disabilities (pp. 3–24). Mahwah, NJ:Erlbaum.
      Google Scholar
    • Scarborough, H. S., & Dobrich, W. (1990). Development of children with early language delay.Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 33, 70–83.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Share, D. L., & Silva, P. A. (1987). Language deficits and specific reading retardation: Cause or effect?.British Journal of Disorders of Communication, 22, 219–226.
      Google Scholar
    • Shaywitz, B. A., Fletcher, J. M., Holahan, J. M., & Shaywitz, S. E. (1993). Discrepancy compared to low achievement definitions of reading disability: Results from the Connecticut Longitudinal Study.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 639–648.
      Google Scholar
    • Shaywitz, S. E., Escobar, M. D., Shaywitz, B. A., Fletcher, J. M., & Makuch, R. (1992). Evidence that dyslexia may represent the lower tail of a normal distribution of reading ability.New England Journal of Medicine, 326, 145–150.
      Google Scholar
    • Shaywitz, S. E., Shaywitz, B. A., Fletcher, J. M., & Escobar, M. D. (1990). Prevalence of reading disability in boys and girls: Results of the Connecticut Longitudinal Study.Journal of the American Medical Association, 264, 998–1002.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Siegel, L. S. (1989). Is IQ irrelevant to the definition of learning disabilities?.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 469–478.
      Google Scholar
    • Silva, P. A. (1980). The prevalence, stability and significance of developmental language delay in preschool children.Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 22, 768–777.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Silva, P. A., Williams, S., & McGee, R. (1987). A longitudinal study of children with developmental language delay at age three: Later intelligence, reading and behavior problems.Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 29, 630–640.
      Google Scholar
    • Snowling, M. J. (1981). Phonemic deficits in developmental dyslexia.Psychological Research, 43, 219–234.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Snowling, M. J., Bishop, D. V. M., & Stothard, S. E. (2000). Is preschool language impairment a risk factor for dyslexia in adolescence?.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 41, 587–600.
      Google Scholar
    • Snowling, M. J., Gallagher, A., & Frith, U. (2003). Family risk of dyslexia is continuous: Individual differences in the precursors of reading skill.Child Development, 74, 358–373.
      CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar
    • Stanovich, K. E. (1986). Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy.Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360–364.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Stanovich, K. E. (1988). Children’s reading and the development of phonological awareness..Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.
      Google Scholar
    • Stanovich, K. E., & Siegel, L. S. (1994). Phenotypic performance profile of reading-disabled children: A regressionbased test of the phonological-core variable-difference model.Journal of Educational Psychology, 86, 24–53.
      Google Scholar
    • Stark, R. E., & Tallal, P. (1981). Selection of children with specific language deficits.Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 46, 114–122.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Stothard, S. E., & Hulme, C. (1995). A comparison of phonological skills in children with reading comprehension difficulties and children with decoding difficulties.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 36, 399–408.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Tager-Flusberg, H., & Cooper, J. (1999). Present and future possibilities for defining a phenotype for specific language impairment.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 42, 1275–1278.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Tallal, P. (2003). Language learning disabilities: Integrating research approaches.Current Directions in Psychological Science, 12, 206–211.
      Google Scholar
    • Tallal, P., Allard, L., & Curtiss, S. (1988). Academic outcomes of language impaired children.Unpublished manuscript.
      Google Scholar
    • Tallal, P., Allard, L., Miller, S., & Curtiss, S. (1997). Academic outcomes of language impaired children.In C. Hulme & M. J. Snowling (Eds.) Dyslexia: Biology, cognition, and intervention (pp. 167–181). London: Whurr.
      Google Scholar
    • Tomblin, J. B., Records, N., Buckwalter, P., Zhang, X., Smith, E., & O’Brien, M. (1997). Prevalence of specific language impairment in kindergarten children.Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 40, 1245–1260.
      ASHAWireGoogle Scholar
    • Tomblin, J. B., Records, N. L., & Zhang, X. (1996). A system for the diagnosis of specific language impairment in kindergarten children.Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 40, 1284–1294.
      Google Scholar
    • Tomblin, J. B., Zhang, X., Weiss, A., Catts, H., & EllisWeismer, S. (2004). Dimensions of individual differences in communication skills among primary grade children.In M. L. Rice & S. F. Warren (Eds.) Developmental language disorders: From phenotypes to etiologies (pp. 53–76).Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
      Google Scholar
    • van Daal, V., & van der Leij, A. (1999). Developmental dyslexia: Related to specific or general deficits?.Annals of Dyslexia, 49, 71–104.
      Google Scholar
    • van der Bob, W. H., & van der Pijl, J. M. L. (1997). Effects of word length and word likeness on pseudoword repetition by poor and normal readers.Applied Psycholinguistics, 18, 101–114.
      Google Scholar
    • Vellutino, F. R., & Scanlon, D. M. (Eds.). (1982). Verbal processing in poor and normal readers. New York: Springer-Verlag.
      Google Scholar
    • Vellutino, F. R., Scanlon, D. M., & Lyon, G. R. (2000). Differentiating between difficult-to-remediate and readily remediated poor readers: More evidence against the IQ– achievement discrepancy definition of reading disability.Journal of Learning Disabilities, 33, 223–238.
      Google Scholar
    • Wechsler, D. (1989). Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence—Revised.New York: Psychological Corporation.
      Google Scholar
    • Wechsler, D. (1991). Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children—III.San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corporation.
      Google Scholar
    • Wimmer, H., Mayringer, H., & Landerl, K. (2000). The double-deficit hypothesis and difficulties in learning to read a regular orthography.Journal of Educational Psychology, 92, 668–680.
      CrossrefGoogle Scholar
    • Woodcock, R. (1987). Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests— Revised.Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
      Google Scholar

    Additional Resources