No AccessJournal of Speech, Language, and Hearing ResearchResearch Article1 Jun 2003

Three Treatments for Teachers With Voice Disorders

A Randomized Clinical Trial

    Voice problems are a common occupational hazard of teaching school, yet few studies exist that have objectively evaluated treatment approaches aimed at rehabilitating these occupation-related voice disorders. This randomized clinical trial used patient-based treatment outcome measures to evaluate the effectiveness of three treatment programs. Sixty-four teachers with voice disorders were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 treatment groups: voice amplification using the ChatterVox portable amplifier (VA; n = 25), resonance therapy (RT; n = 19), and respiratory muscle training (RMT; n = 20). Before and after a 6-week treatment phase, all teachers completed (a) the Voice Handicap Index (VHI; B. H. Jacobson et al., 1997), an instrument designed to appraise the self-perceived psychosocial consequences of voice disorders, and (b) a voice severity self-rating scale. Both intention-to-treat and as-treated analyses revealed that only the VA and RT groups reported significant reductions in mean VHI scores and in voice severity selfratings following treatment. Furthermore, results from a posttreatment questionnaire regarding the perceived benefits of treatment showed that compared to RT and RMT, teachers in the VA group reported significantly more overall voice improvement, greater vocal clarity, and greater ease of speaking and singing voice following treatment. These findings replicate previous results from an earlier clinical trial confirming the efficacy of VA and provide new evidence to support RT as an effective treatment alternative for voice problems in teachers. The results are discussed in the context of uneven levels of self-reported compliance and disparate dropout rates among the treatment groups.

    References

    • Baker, S., Sapienza, C., Davenport, P., Martin, D., Hoffman-Ruddy, B., & Woodson, G. (in press). Inspiratory muscle training in a patient with bilateral abductor vocal fold paresis. Journal of Voice.
    • Digest of Education Statistics. (2000). Chapter 1—All levels of education. Table 4. Retrieved March 14, 2003 from National Center for Education Statistics Electronic Catalog: http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2001/digest/ch1.asp#1
    • Frederic, A., Pugliano, J. F., & Piccirillo, J. F. (1999). Outcomes research. In C. W.Cummings, J. M.Fredrickson, L. A.Harker, C. J.Krauss, M. A.Richardson, & D. E.Schuller, (Eds.), Otolaryngology-head & neck surgery ( Vol. 1, 3rd ed., pp. 380–387). St. Louis: Mosby.
    • Friedman, L. M., Furberg, C. D., & DeMets, D. L. (1998). Fundamentals of clinical trials (3rd ed.). New York: Springer.
    • Fritzell, B. (1996). Voice disorders and occupations. Logopedics, Phoniatrics, and Vocology, 21, 7–12.
    • Gotaas, C., & Starr, C. D. (1993). Vocal fatigue among teachers, Folia Phoniatrica, 45, 120–129.
    • Herrington-Hall, B. L., Lee, L., Stemple, J. C., Niemi, K. R., & McHone, M. M. (1988). Description of laryngeal pathology by age, sex, and occupation in a treatmentseeking sample. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 53, 57–64.
    • Hoffman-Ruddy, B. (2002, June). Traditional and unique strategies for treating injured singing voices. Workshop presented at The Voice Foundation 31st Annual Symposium: Care of the Professional Voice, Philadelphia.
    • Hoffman-Ruddy, B., Lehman, J., Crandell, C., Ingram, D., & Sapienza, C. M. (2001). High-risk performers: Laryngostroboscopic and acoustic characteristics. Journal of Voice, 15, 543–552.
    • Hoffman-Ruddy, B., Sapienza, C., Lehman, J., Davenport, P., & Martin, D. (2001, June). Expiratory pressure threshold training in high risk singers. Paper presented at the The Voice Foundation 30th Annual Voice Symposium: Care of the Professional Voice, Philadelphia.
    • Hogikyan, N. D., & Rosen, C. A. (2002). A review of outcome measurements for voice disorders. Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, 126, 562–572.
    • Jacobson, B. H., Johnson, A., Grywalski, C., Silbergleit, A., Jacobson, G., Benninger, M., et al. (1997). The Voice Handicap Index (VHI): Development and validation. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 6(3), 66–70.
    • Mattiske, J. A., Oates, J. M., & Greenwood, K. M. (1998). Vocal problems among teachers: A review of prevalence, causes, prevention, and treatment. Journal of Voice, 12, 489–499.
    • McCormick, C., & Roy, N. (2002). The ChatterVox portable voice amplifier: A means to vibration dose reduction in occupational voice users. Journal of Voice, 16, 502–508.
    • Olson, D., Davenport, P., Sapienza, C., Martin, D., & Knafelc, M. (2001, April). Specific expiratory muscle strength training in adult male deep water U.S. Navy divers. Paper presented at the Experimental Biology: Spring Conference, Orlando, FL.
    • Pekkarinen, E., Himberg, L, & Pentti, J. (1992). Prevalence of vocal symptoms among teachers compared with nurses: A questionnaire study. Scandinavian Journal of Logopedics and Phoniatrics, 17, 112–117.
    • Pekkarinen, E., & Viljanen, V. (1991). Acoustic conditions for speech communcation in classrooms. Sandinavian Audiology, 20, 257–263.
    • Rantala, L., Haataja, K., & Vilkman, E. (1997). Measuring voice under teachers' working circumstances: F0 and perturbation features in maximally sustained phonation. Folia Phoniatrica and Logopedics, 49, 281–291.
    • Rantala, L., Paavola, L., Korkko, P., & Vilkman, E. (1998). Working-day effects on the spectral characteristics of teaching voice. Folia Phoniatrica and Logopedics, 50, 205–211.
    • Rosen, C. A., Murry, T., Zinn, A., Zullo, T., & Sonbolian, M. (2000). Voice Handicap Index change following treatment of voice disorders. Journal of Voice, 14, 619–623.
    • Roy, N., Gray, S. D., Simon, M., Dove, H., Corbin-Lewis, K., & Stemple, J. C. (2001). An evaluation of the effects of two treatment approaches for teachers with voice disorders: A prospective randomized clinical trial. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 44, 286–296.
    • Roy, N., Weinrich, B., Gray, S. D., Tanner, K., Walker Toledo, S., Dove, H., et al.. (2002). Voice amplification versus vocal hygiene instruction for teachers with voice disorders: A treatment outcomes study. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 45, 625–638.
    • Russell, A., Oates, J., & Greenwood, K. M. (1998). Prevalence of voice problems in teachers. Journal of Voice, 12, 467–479.
    • Sabol, J. W., Lee, L., & Stemple, J. C. (1995). The value of vocal function exercises in the practice regimen of singers. Journal of Voice, 9, 27–36.
    • Sapienza, C., Davenport, P., & Martin, D. (2002). Expiratory muscle training increases pressure support in high school band students. Journal of Voice, 16, 495–501.
    • Sapienza, C. M., Brown, J., Martin, D., & Davenport, P. (1999). Inspiratory pressure threshold training for glottal airway limitation in laryngeal papilloma. Journal of Voice, 13, 382–388.
    • Sapienza, C. M., Crandell, C. C., & Curtis, B. (1999). Effects of sound-field frequency modulation amplification on reducing teacher's sound pressure level in the classroom. Journal of Voice, 13, 375–381.
    • Sapienza, C. M., Hoffman-Ruddy, B., Davenport, P., Martin, D., & Lehman, J. (2001, September). Acoustic and physiological characteristics of high-risk vocal performers following expiratory pressure training. Paper presented at the 17th International Congress on Acoustics, Rome.
    • Smith, E., Gray, S. D., Dove, H., Kirchner, L., & Heras, H. (1997). Frequency and effects of teachers' voice problems. Journal of Voice, 11, 81–87.
    • Smith, E., Kirchner, H. L., Taylor, M., Hoffman, H., & Lemke, J. H. (1998). Voice problems among teachers: Differences by gender and teaching characteristics. Journal of Voice, 12, 328–334.
    • Smith, E., Lemke, J., Taylor, M., Kirchner, H. L., & Hoffman, H. (1998). Frequency of voice problems among teachers and other occupations. Journal of Voice, 12, 480–488.
    • Stemple, J. (2000). Voice therapy: Clinical studies (2nd ed.). San Diego, CA: Singular.
    • Stemple, J., Glaze, L., & Klaben, B. (2000). Clinical voice pathology: Theory & management (3rd ed.). San Diego, CA: Singular.
    • Stemple, J. C., Lee, L., D'Amico, B., & Pickup, B. (1994). Efficacy of vocal function exercises as a method of improving voice production. Journal of Voice, 8, 271–278.
    • Titze, I. R. (1994). Principles of voice production. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
    • Titze, I. R. (2001). Acoustic interpretation of resonant voice. Journal of Voice, 15, 519–528.
    • Titze, I. R., Lemke, J., & Montequin, D. (1997). Populations in the U.S. workforce who rely on voice as a primary tool of trade: A preliminary report. Journal of Voice, 11, 254–259.
    • Verdolini, K. (2000). Resonant voice therapy. In J. C.Stemple (Ed.), Voice therapy: Clinical studies (2nd ed.; pp. 46–61). San Diego, CA: Singular.
    • Verdolini, K., Druker, D. G., Palmer, P. M., & Samawi, H. (1998). Laryngeal adduction in resonant voice. Journal of Voice, 12, 315–327.
    • Verdolini, K., & Ramig, L. O. (2001). Review: Occupational risks for voice problems. Logopedics, Phoniatrics, and Vocology, 26, 37–46.
    • Verdolini-Marston, K., Burke, M. K., Lessac, A., Glaze, L., & Caldwell, E. (1995). Preliminary study of two methods of treatment for laryngeal nodules. Journal of Voice, 9, 74–85.

    Additional Resources